Mission Challenges from Contemporary India: That they may be one, that the world may know …. John 17.
Subtitle: Looking for a Fourth Way in Missiology and Moving from Church based Ecumenism to Cultural Ecumenism
It is indeed a great privilege for me to present this paper here. I am thankful to all who have organised this seminar, proposed my name for this lecture and all who are here with great expectations. I teach Christian Communication as a subject which brings together new areas of mission and I am interested in the contemporary ecumenical issues rather than bring back some issues from the history of missions in India. I will also try to connect them to the British context if not during the discussion time we can raise together some of the similar issues in doing mission in both contexts. I should confess the fact that in this simple paper I cannot discuss all the mission issues in India. I cannot also claim to represent all the churches in India particularly those churches in the North Eastern part of India and also new emerging churches in India though I may refer to them at times in this paper.
Christian mission is a movement of the people of God in their contexts. When there is a crisis in their context the mission of God is to recognise, engage and address with it and thus witness Christ in and through their words, lives and action. Today in India we are faced with religious fundamentalism, linguistic chauvinism, caste exploitation, political vengeance and ideological conflicts in different parts. The root cause of all these issues is poverty. The rich people’s refusal to share their wealth, the natural disasters and government inability to serve the billions of people are some of the reasons for poverty. Unless churches or Christian communities address this issue strategically it is impossible to do any kind of mission in India. Christians alone cannot address this issue by doing charity or some projects. Rather they have to work together with other denominations, other religious communities and other ideological groups at various levels. In order to strategically develop mission thinking and mission action, the Christian communities have to find new ways of relating themselves with people of other faiths, people of other castes and people of other doctrines.
The churches find it difficult to nourish the wider cultural groups within their structure or their doctrines to create such as wider ecumenical or multicultural communities to address the problems together. But one has to recognise the fact that the cultural gatherings such as varanda (frontier of the house) and tree gatherings, marriages, funeral meetings, cottage prayers, prayer halls, revival gatherings, clubs and teashop discussions are such encounters are happening and are nourished by the community with the wider interests. Christians often relate with others in these cultural gatherings where they relate themselves in different ways. It is essential to encourage Christians to engage in such alternative spaces where they can ecumenically work together with other denominational Christians in sharing their resources, information and thus bringing about changes in their communities. To nourish such alternative cultural spaces, I am developing a model by holding a dialogue between Mahatma Gandhi (self-reliance of community), Amertya Sen (freedom), Habermas (Public space) and Yunis (Micro economics). The present theological proposals for relating with others in order to engage with these issues such as exclusive, inclusive and pluralistic methods are not helpful in engaging and bring about transformation within the Christian communities and thereby with others as well. Unless we take grassroots Christians and their simple faith in mission (which is to maintain the uniqueness and universal relevance of the Gospel) seriously we may not find a common ground to encourage them to engage in such wider cultural interactions.
The grassroots Christians may find a middle way of maintaining their faith in Christ as the Truth without offending other faiths or claiming superiority over others. Because they do not experience God through others’ religious faith and narratives, they cannot compare with their own and so they cannot make judgemental statements about others’ faith. Their own Christian faith though unique and universally relevant and God has revealed through Christ completely, still God cannot be contained in one of the Christian doctrines or denominational statements. In this sense Christian narratives are not gods rather they enable Christians to relate themselves to God through Christ. In this way too Christians can proclaim their narratives of the Gospel through words, action and lives and thus invite others to accept them while recognise the fact that the narratives are not the absolute in themselves. It is the Triune God who is the absolute but mysterious and cannot be contained in any human narrative completely. These narratives are secondary to the relationship with God and also relationship with human beings. It affirms the life of every human being and thus becomes relevant both to Christian faith and common values of humanity.
If Christians wish to work with their friends towards eliminating the poverty through an alternative community possibly outside the church with good relationship and coordination among them while they maintain the fact that they would like to witness Christ in every action and invite people of other faith to their own while listening to their faith stories as well. It means they will not make any judgement of other faiths and respect people of other faiths and their friendship.
If their relationship and friendship are stronger then they may critically and creatively engage with each other’s faith. This is neither inclusive nor exclusive nor pluralistic rather a fourth way which accommodates the Christian aspirations to share and witness their Gospel without hesitation while being careful not to offend people of other faiths either by condemning or by judging their traditions and experiences. This is what I call as fourth way in doing mission in Indian context. My fourth way is to encourage Christian communities not only to engage with people from other denominations and other traditions but also with other faith communities in order to address together the issue of poverty and thus all other related issues. By bringing people together to eliminate poverty from across different traditions, denominations and religious faiths, lay Christians and so the church leaders may be able witness Christ in different ways in India. Such attempt addresses the issue of development and poverty, interfaith relationship and also Christian witnessing in new ways in Indian context. This is also a pragmatic way of doing mission among the multicultural communities.
Starting with Poverty in India:
Poverty is the worst form of Violence
There are people in the world so hungry, that God cannot appear to them except in the form of bread..... Mahatma Gandhi
Poverty is the parent of revolution and crime. – Aristotle
If we enable people to come out of poverty in India we may be able to reduce the conflicts, discrimination and exploitation among the communities to a large extent. It is the refusal of people to share their resources or control them in a way others do not have access to them and thus control the freedom of people to earn for their basic needs which can lead to conflicts often between communities or individuals. The role of a Christian missiologist is to enable the churches, agencies, Christians to develop strategies of mission that would encourage them to create community space for addressing the issue of poverty of the people in India.
At present Indian society have a few richest people in the World. Even after recession they seem to be in list of the richest people in the world. It is true that there is a considerable middle class who have improved their lives and have become upper middle class . Because it is in large number even the churches have considerable rich people in the church. To run a normal life at present as a middle class in Indian rural set up around 200 US dollars per month are approximately enough and in an urban set up 250 to 300 US dollars are just enough. But the normal income for any person working in any reasonable local company or government institutions is more than this amount. In any international call centres or Indian multinational company the normal salaries are 600 to 2000 US dollars per month. Many the professionals get into this job and become elite in the society. They are mainly engineers and software professionals who get these pays. After the recession too the growth of the companies is not fast but jobs are reduced to some extent but not in the same speed as in the West as the salaries given to the staff are not high as in the West and so less jobs are cut.
There is another side to Indian society where 20% of the population have to struggle for one time food a day. It means 200 million people are living under poverty line according to the statistics of the Indian government . It is certainly more than the total population of the Britain. On the one hand those who live under poverty line (People Below Poverty line –PBL) have decreased since independence but on the other hand those people who live under poverty line are still in great numbers. Many children die of malnutrition or hunger in different parts of India which does not become news worthy of publishing in any Indian newspaper. This is the contradiction in Indian society. Unless this issue of poverty is addressed the question about terrorism and religious violence in the society cannot fully be addressed. It is time that those who are involved in mission activities take sides with these people who are living under poverty line.
Poverty in India?!
Poverty in India is caused by many reasons. There are people who live in poverty for generations. Natural disasters such as flood, drought; war and conflicts; exploitation and scarcity of food and refusal to share resources are a few causes for poverty. In simple terms there are 200 millions of people struggling for their basic needs who are identified as people who live below poverty line in India. I agree with Amartya Sen, Nobel price winner in 1998 for economic philosophy, when he says the poverty cannot solely be determined by the economic income of a particular person rather by the freedom that person has to earn his basic needs within a particular environment. According to Sen, “being a poor does not mean living below an imaginary poverty line, such as an income of two dollars a day or less. It means having an income level that does not allow an individual to cover certain basic necessities, taking into account the circumstances and social requirements of the environment” . He then focuses on the other factors that enable an individual to find income to cover or not to cover the basic necessities. He goes on to say, “There are geographical, biological and social factors that amplify or reduce the impact of income on each individual. The poor generally lack a number of elements, such as education, access to land, health and longevity, justice, family and community support, credit and other productive resources, a voice in institutions, and access to opportunity . The poor are constrained in a way that their basic needs are under control of someone else. Their income, education and support from the government are controlled so that they do not get the freedom to meet their basic needs and develop themselves. In another words I would also argue that not only they are constrained but they were not able to find an alternative space where they can express and experience such freedom.
Poverty is thus seen as a lack of freedoms, as an unfreedom . And development can be regarded as “the removal of various types of unfreedoms that leave people with little choice and little opportunity of exercising their reasoned agency.” Development is a matter of liberating people of what makes them unfree, of what prevents them to live a life they would have reason to choose and value. For me I wish to argue in a different way . Development is not to remove the various types of unfreedoms rather create community alternative spaces where they can find freedom to move away from the poverty. For me liberating people means to enable them to liberate themselves by finding alternative spaces when the existing structure does not allow them to either work against or transform it completely. There may be individual motivations but organised effort within an alternative community can bring about micro level and macro level transformations within the society at large.
So if it demands on focussing on the environment where an individual is not allowed to exercise the freedom to earn his livelihood. One may blame the structures of society such as caste systems and other political systems that control and constraint such freedom and thus do not allow people to come out of their poverty. It is difficult to change the structures that are controlled by cultural worldviews and other power centres in the communities which are not easy to change or transform. Secondly the motivating individuals to change their environment radically may also not possible as collective mindset may not be brought immediately at mass level in order to make people to bring about changes.
While I agree that there should be structural changes at wider level and also be motivational transformation at individual level, one may have to think about something more than these two which are influencing each other and intersecting and thus bringing changes into a society. These points remind us of the Anthony Giddens, third way . But my fourth way is to explore whether the Christians or mission agencies or possibly churches can work with Non governmental, governmental agencies or Faith based organisations to create, sustain and nourish the alternative community space or environment that would allow people to use their freedom to earn their basic needs. It is more than mere charity rather may be called investment on small communities and groups. It argues that both structural changes and developing individual’s skills are not enough rather organising small group and community network to create, realise and use a common space in order to created freedom to earn what they like to.
In this sense alternative is not to replace or counter the wider community rather to work closely within it. It is a community of freedom and values that enables the participants to meet their basic needs and also to enhance a new type or form of relationship among the community members. It believes in the value of developing a multicultural community. It also affirms the commitment to equality of opportunity. It emphasises the responsibility and accountability of the communities. Some of these are basic characteristics of third way . But it goes beyond in the sense the community is a new one where gender, caste, race and linguistic groups recognise and respect each other. They also share resources with each other. It creates an alternative structure within itself and the purpose is to build relationship and friendship; share resources and information, values and faiths and also worldviews.
One has also to be sensitive to the resources available for the large number of people to create such an environment. At times the nature is not in favour of the people at particular places. For example situation of draught for a longer period of time can bring scarcity of food and opportunities in that part and then the grains have to be supplied from other places. To create such an environment with or without the support of the local government, people and also other agencies have to work together. Is this possible? Am I living in an ideal world? Am I simply living in a dream world? Such things might be possible. My question is also whether the churches can engage in this process?
Example: “Yunus was an economics professor in his native Bangladesh in 1974 when he decided to understand why economic theories seemed not to work in the everyday realities that surrounded him. He ventured into a nearby neighborhood where he met a young woman who made stools out of bamboo. She was borrowing money from a trader who then required her to sell the finished product back to him, leaving her with only about 2 cents per day for herself. Yunus decided to lend her $6, which was enough for her to buy her own bamboo. Right away, she began earning $1.25 per day, which made a huge difference.
In all, Yunus found 42 people in that neighborhood who needed a combined total of $27 to become more self-sufficient. He lent them the money out of his pocket. All of them repaid him. When Yunus took his idea to banks, he found no one willing to help. So he formed his own, the Grameen Bank. Now, other banks have been formed to make similar loans. ”
In his nobel price lecture he said, Poverty is a threat to peace and poverty is denial of all human beings . He told how his initiative in and through Grameen bank has brought about transformation among the beggers in Bangladesh. In his lecture in 2006, he said, In Bangladesh 80 percent of the poor families have already been reached with microcredit. We are hoping that by 2010, 100 per cent of the poor families will be reached. Three years ago we started an exclusive programme focusing on the beggars. None of Grameen Bank's rules apply to them. Loans are interest-free; they can pay whatever amount they wish, whenever they wish. We gave them the idea to carry small merchandise such as snacks, toys or household items, when they went from house to house for begging. The idea worked. There are now 85,000 beggars in the program. About 5,000 of them have already stopped begging completely. Typical loan to a beggar is $12. We encourage and support every conceivable intervention to help the poor fight out of poverty. We always advocate microcredit in addition to all other interventions, arguing that microcredit makes those interventions work better .
I had the privilege of working with Grameen Network on Communications during my tenure in World Association for Christian Communication and worked with them in providing IT training for the marginalised people and developing communities at large in small groups. The grameem bank provided me examples of how developing and funding small community groups can succeed in business, innovation and investments. I have seen their success in Dhaka among the slums. Yunus strongly believes that they can put poverty in the museums .
Building such communities at grassroots that would create a freedom among themselves in order to enable people to earn their basic needs and possibly more. Focussing on marginal communities with micro-investments, skills, information, networking in business and organisational structures can help people to create this freedom. Tamil Nadu government has introduced self-help groups among women to develop similar schemes that seem to have worked reasonably well in many places.
Interestingly Hebermas suggested that such a community space existed in Europe in 18th century. It is true such community spaces existed even in India. Unfortunately many of them became caste centred and male dominated Panchayats or tree shadow meetings. One of my students did a research about the tea shops in Kerala where such community centres were redeveloped through which much awareness about issues have developed and thus led to awareness of buying local things. Habermas pointed out to communicative public space which can be a transformative space through rational discourse and interactions between individuals and groups. There is a freedom to express and share one’s ideas and values and critically engage with them while there is no coercions within such community space among the members. Transformative changes within the community cannot be created merely with the freedom to earn their basic needs but also freedom to express and share among them.
First we identified poverty as constraints on freedom of the people that would enable them to meet their basic necessities. We argued that there is a need to proactively create a community space where such freedom can be exercised rather than merely changing the structures and motivating individuals to bring about changes. We see such changes are possible and were realised in Bangladesh through Grameen systems. But we also see that the freedom has to include not only the freedom to make their lives but also freedom to express and shape each other’s ideas and concepts to build the community further is essential part of the community formation.
Such a community at local level has to be developed not only for relationship building but also for people’s sharing of resources, for creating freedom; for building support system for needed persons such as the differently-able or those who are struck by the disasters and so on and also for developing a communicative and transformative community within local area. Such community has to depend on the local resources and negotiate itself with other communities at different levels even at the global level. How far such a community can become self-reliant in terms of achieving its freedom where everyone is able to meet his or her own basic needs? It is the basic question that we need to ask. Local community based on the local resources and thus make the community to supply to meet the basic needs of the local people and then serve the wider community at large. Here I am careful not to identify the local community with natives and non-natives which is a dangerous identity issue. There is no local community which has any homogenous or one single identity but share a multiple and multicultural identities. If we are developing a community then we have to take into account this multi-identity as part of the commonness of the community and possibly a shared humanity rather than any particular identity though in some cases such identity become dominant or majority within the community or even become the only identity in terms of caste or race or language.
Gandhi struggled with the similar themes in his writings about ‘swedhesi concept’. It means to make local communities self-reliant not completely in terms of eliminating dependency rather means to support local resources and thus create a community where such a freedom to meet one’s own needs can be met only when there is a positive attitude to support local suppliers. Let me put this in Gandhi’s own term, “If we follow the Swadeshi doctrine, it would be your duty and mine to find out neighbours who can supply our wants and to teach them to supply them where they do not know how to proceed, assuming that there are neighbours who are in want of healthy occupation. Then every village of India will almost be a self-supporting and self-contained unit, exchanging only such necessary commodities with other villages as are not locally producible”. Gandhi’s vision of building local communities with local resources needs to be recognised. But in a global context there should be a negotiation between what we can take from local context and what we can take from international contexts. Gandhi rightly pointed out one is not exclusive of the other rather the local community needs to be developed and supported and cannot be neglected at the cost of global business.
After developing a dialogue between Sen, Yunus, Habermas and Gandhi, I wish to highlight that the poverty can be addressed not merely by the structural changes or transformation of nations at large nor merely by motivating individuals and by providing them skills but by creating inter-mediatory and immediate communitarian type of networks that might help to bring people together for developing a space for freedom to earn, express and engage in eliminating the poverty of one’s own and of others too. This space has to negotiate between local, national and global institutions in the process of transforming themselves. I call this alternative community which would give a space for the churches in India to bring about transformation at local and national levels. My aim of this paper is to encourage churches to think about creating such space within every community in which they exist. Let me give an example from the Self-help groups . If you happen to visit gurudwaras one of the important activities that have sustained the community lives among Sikhs is sharing of food. It is not charity as they call it sharing of God’s gifts . Such practices can be found in Ashrams too. I am not suggesting a kind of free food sharing community rather I wish to see that Christians can actively engage in creating such community spaces where freedom to earn for oneself or for one’s family and to share one’s resources in terms of investment can be made possible. Whether this can be part of mission of the Christians at large is my primary question with which I move to churches in India about their present activities and any possible strategies that the churches have to consider in order to engage in such activities.
Churches in India
Here I am starting with a few statements here about the churches in India. First the spirit of union is no more present among the churches in India that is to come together as one church – The church of India as the churches would like to maintain their own identity. Secondly many established churches are either being influenced by the Charismatic or prosperity oriented gospel that many Christians are concerned about their own well beings, their own individual salvation and their own fortunes. On other hand many churches are concerned about the conversion of all non-Christians into Christianity and give a lot of money for such activities from their income to those missionary organisations that carry out such evangelisations of non-Christians particularly in the Northern part of India. Indian churches are growing not simply because of these charismatic and ultra evangelical groups rather because of the witness of the ordinary Christian people who share their wisdom, information resources and their love with their fellow human beings from other communities .
Of course many churches in India have concern for the poor and do a lot of charity and development work among the marginalised and economically backward people. Churches run a large number of schools and other developmental organisations . For such projects and organisation they often depend on the foreign funds though there are a few emerging exceptions in raising funds from within the churches and Christians in India. Of course I would also criticise churches for some of their corrupt ways of conducting elections, selling properties and misappropriation of foreign funds and so on .
There are a few Christian leaders who think of genuine Christian mission. They would like to proclaim, witness for and invite people to Christ, send missionaries who would bring about transformation among the poor and the neglected people of the society; listen and interact with people from different faiths and also engage in their struggles for creating a community of freedom . There is a need for strategic thinking in mission which can address the issue of poverty at large in India and elsewhere rather than simply focussing only on a few charity or developmental projects. There has been a wide range of discussion in addressing these issues among the theological colleges. I will start with the context of poverty in India and why do we need thinking and doing to go together in Christian mission.
In order to address the issue of poverty in India it is essential that the churches think strategically in doing mission and develop concepts, perspectives, theologies and practical models for bringing to the notice of the wider communities at large. This is what sets my paper a background for developing “ Fourth Way Missiology” in order to bring about social changes in contexts such as India, and to make the gospel alive and thus witness to Christ to all communities through the activities of the churches in today’s context.
Ecumenical Journey of Churches in India
The first part of 20th century the churches in India were in the mood of union and thus engaged in the process of creating the Church of India. It was first realised on September 27, 1947, when Bishop C K Jacob (Central Travancore Diocese) uttered the Declaration of CSI,
“Dearly Beloved Brethren, in obedience to the Lord Jesus Christ, the Head of the Church, on the night of His Passion prayed that His disciples might be one, and by authority of the governing bodies of the uniting churches, whose resolution has been read in your hearing and laid in prayer before Almighty God. I do hereby declare that these churches.....have become one Church of South India....In the Name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. Amen”.
It was already stated by the Founding fathers in their vision at the famous Tranquebar meeting in May 1919 . It was the missionary movements that were coming together in various places and at various times to work out the possibilities of collaboration in India with themes such as “Comity and Collaboration” and Church of Christ in India and also with issues such as self-support, indigenisation, self-government and self-reliance . Missionary agencies were forerunners in forming this union since 1924s and even earlier in other ways. The CMS and SPG merged in 1924 into a single diocese in Tirunelveli which was a significant forerunner of the Church Union in South India (George p.67). I have used the CSI as an example where grassroots too were part and parcel of this union and is also a growing church and will remain a challenge to the churches not only in India but also around the world . .
A similar story can be heard from the Church of North India too. The Church of North India is one of the best examples of the ecumenical union and covers larger areas than the CSI. Their church too has been growing in every possible ways The discussions began in 1929 and the ecumenical union was formed in 1970 including the Baptists, Brethren, Anglicans and others . One should point out to the fact that it was movements outside the churches that were making a lot of impact on the churches and enabling them towards such a great union both in the South and in the North.
There were also movements outside or inside the church that were enabling people to come together for various other reasons such as Christian Literature Society, the Christian Endeavour Conventions, the YMCA (1890), The Student Christian Movement of India and Ceylon (1896), Indian Missionary Society (1903), NMS (1904). There were individual leaders who were part of these movements such as G S Eddy, V S Azariah, K T Paul, C J Lucas, V.Santiago and A J Appasamy. Some educational institutions too played a key role in these unions such as MCC, Chennai, WCC, Chennai, UTC, Bangalore, Jaffna College, Ceylon. (Gladstone p.8)
The purpose of the union of the churches is clearly stated in the constitution of the Church of South India by saying,
“The Church of South India acknowledges that in every effort to bring together divided members of the church’s body into one organisation, the final aim must be the union in the universal church of all who acknowledge the name of Christ” (Constitution Chapter II Rule 2).” (George p.10)
and also by saying,
“Therefore the Church of South India purposes ever to be mindful of its missionary calling and prays that it may not only be greatly used of God for the evangelisation of South India, but may also take its due share in the preaching of the Gospel and the building up of Christ’s church in other parts of the world.” (Ch II, 3 – George p.13).
The dialogue between the CSI leaders and Lutheran churches’ representatives continued in India after 1947 until recently resulting in formation of the Inter church commission and also joint operation of a number of theological colleges in India. (George 149). The CSI, CNI and Marthoma churches have continued their discussions even proposing name for the new church in India as the Uniting Church in India or The Church in India and Bharat Christian Church in 1982. Though CSI and CNI wish to combine into one church, the Marthoma churches were concerned about their identity.
In 1985 joint council executive committee began to raise questions about merger into one single church which will be called the Church of India rather wishes to remain in communion with each other into ‘organic oneness’ in which each church accepts others’ faith, ministry and sacraments. (George 156). It is often stated that the churches are no more interested in merging of the churches into one homogenous church – which might be called the Church of India though there were vigorous dialogue among the CSI, CNI and also Marthoma churches. The ecumenical vision with which CSI and CNI were formed in 1947 and 1970 no more shared by the present church leaders though there is a widen ecumenical mission that bring the churches together in other ways. There are in full communion with each other in the sense that they accept each other’s members, ordination and Bishopric and often have joint programmes at various levels.
It has become increasingly difficult for the churches in India to unite themselves into one church – The Church of India. It will be very good if CSI, CNI and Marthoma churches can think about it without loosing one’s own identity or one dominating the other in some ways. Of course oneness is not pointing to sameness and unity is not pointing to uniformity. We can come together only outside our structure of the churches and form a common space where we can work together in order to address and eliminate poverty. Lutheran Churches and Methodist Church of India in North did not join the union but they work in close association with CSI, CNI and other churches. There are other growing evangelical churches such as Evangelical Church of India, Gospel for Asia and Baptist, Presbyterian churches in the North East India work at various levels closely with the other churches. Pentecostal and Charismatic churches are also coming closer at times in terms of issues and problems they face as being minorities. United Theological College has been pioneer in such ecumenical adventures including having staff from Orthodox to Pentecostals, Roman Catholics to Charismatic groups and other regular established churches and thus give a foretaste of possible ecumenical activities in India. Senate of Serampore is also a good example in giving affiliation to wide range of churches’ theological institutions including those of Pentecostal and charismatic groups.
There are also disputes within some churches over the properties and church positions that lead people to take matters into courts. Some churches were involved in reconciliatory activities to come together. In spite of all these fringe ecumenical visions and activities the church today have developed structures and power centres which make it impossible to make any initiatives in this regard. But the church related organisations and church supported organisations get involved in various activities that bring people from different denominations and from different religions together in order to work towards human rights issues, community development, interfaith activities and ecological awareness. The established churches such as CSI or CNI or Marthoma are not able to work within their structures with other faiths such as Hindus or Muslim or with other denominations such as Pentecostal or Catholic churches. One of my students from North Eastern Part of India wrote his research on how Baptists, Catholics and Pentecostals cannot get along or speak against each others on Sundays in their churches. While on Mondays they had to work together in their government offices. Particularly during a cultural festival “Moatsu” they had to hold each other and dance together. It is the culture that brings people together neither the worship services nor the churches. I hear recently from one of my Fijian students that Indians and Fijians use “Cava” as a drink to come together. Unfortunately the Eucharist cup of Fijians divides the Indian churches and Fijian churches whereas the cultural drink Cava can bring them together.
This is true of marriages and funerals too where relatives and friends from different denominations, religions and castes come together and celebrate the lives together. There are many cultural centres such as tea shops, tree panchayats, Varanda meetings where social issues are discussed, reflected upon, engaged, addressed or acted upon by the community. People find these and other spaces easier for them to come together crossing their boundaries of denominations, religions and even at times castes. Such a space is not to replace the churches’ structured worshipping places. Rather one has to explore whether church can support and nourish such space for discussion, reflections and actions together in creating freedom within the community. Such informal organised spaces can be used for a more formal space for eliminating poverty within the community. Or at least these spaces can be a starting point for an ecumenical journey for the churches.
Whenever there are natural or human made problems faced by the people they tend to come together as well, particularly when the minority institutions are under threat from the government they tend to campaign together against the government. When they issues are addressed together then each one goes on their own ways. In a similar manner natural disasters too cause the people across denominations, religions and caste groups to work together . It means that ecumenical movement is in place except that churches and the grassroots do not get involved because the churches engage in creating a theological barrier or a religious block for the people thus have successfully divided them. In order to create a community space where there will be freedom for the people to share and invest their wealth and also to earn their basic needs through such freedom, it is essential that we encourage Christians and churches to recognise this common space, engage and nourish this space in order to address the issue of poverty in India. To face this the boundaries and barriers have to be overcome but with respect to every tradition, faith and worldviews of each other who may be involved in creating such space.
If the church is creating an alternative community, it has to contain Christians from different denominations and people of other faiths. Such a community is not at all possible for any established churches to create unless they do it outside its regular structure and practices. Creating such alternative communities or open space can certainly reduce the poverty to much extent in India. But there are other difficulties that have to be addressed. First the way the relationship that has to be built with people from other denominations and people from other faiths are complex. Particularly there is tension among Pentecostal churches, Catholic churches and also CSI or CNI or other established churches in coming together in that way. There are also issues among Christians , Hindus and Muslims in coming together in creating alternative space. There are concerns in bringing together various caste groups together for this purpose. These are the three concerns that the churches would have while thinking of creating alternative communities for creating an environment of freedom where poverty issue can be addressed. These issues or constraints make it difficult to develop such community space within the structure of the churches. But such community space exists outside the church structures where people come together often for different purposes and for different reasons. Whether churches can see such existing space and engage in such common space to create an alternative open space.
I will highlight three crises that the church leaders may face in order to bridge this gap and thus enable to create community spaces for freedom and for elimination of poverty. Without addressing the issue of poverty the church can no more do mission within the wider context of India. The first crisis is that of many grassroots Christians who relate with people of other faiths mainly to share their Christian faith, claim the gospel as ultimate truth and thus invite everyone to accept Christ in their lives. They cannot relate or engage with people of other faiths without evangelising or without trying to convert other to their Christian tradition. Second crisis is that many Christians are struggling with their own caste identities particularly in South India whereby they are not in a position to challenge the caste practices outside the churches nor able to invite all caste groups to the same community spaces. Third crisis is that among Christian traditions and new evolving movements there are so much differences and hatred attitude that the member of one church (such as Catholic church) may not consider other Christian as Christian at all. Among the Catholic educational institutions they give preferences to non-Christians after Catholic students than other denominational Christians. It is done similarly among other denominations too.
Interdenominational community space
It is often cultural centres where such interactions used to happen or cultural gatherings where such common issues are discussed and debated in Indian context. In this sense if ecumenism is to bring people together to do God’s mission ecumenically and cross culturally, it is no more happening within the churches rather happening outside the structure and vicinities –particularly in the cultural centres. It may be called “cultural ecumenism” initiated by different groups or organisations or individuals who are interested in such activities of bringing humanity together in order to face the social problems and address them.
The purpose is to develop a community space together with other denominations if possible in order to work together for the betterment of the poor and for the purpose of doing God’s mission. By working together with those who find the common ground rather than try to use the platform to promote their own Christian tradition and faith, it is possible to find a unity that allows everyone to maintain their own tradition but make the work to be shared by all. Here oneness means to refer to working together for a particular purpose of eliminating poverty rather than a permanent union of the churches. After achieving the purpose the churches may still have a kind of friendship or relationship but may not also have such relationship after wards.
My point is that the churches cannot attempt to bring in such spaces into their structures nor into their vicinities. On the other hand church members are involved in one way or the other either a leading role or an active role in such community spaces through their positions or their professions. The churches also have similar spaces within their own communities such as house groups or prayer fellowships and so on. My question is to find out even if there are constraints to bring this within the church, whether the community spaces that exist outside and the existing communities within the churches can be transformed into freedom oriented spaces where people can freely earn their basic needs.
Ecumenical movement is possibly only outside the structural space of the churches. It is my question how the churches can support and sustain and even upheld such movements and encourage participation of the church members unofficially and thus enhance the movement in a wider manner. This raises particularly questions about the relationship between Catholic churches, CSI churches and Charismatic/Pentecostal churches in South India. A few would highlight the ecumenical characteristics of CSI and so be proud of it. The Catholic churches are proud of their tradition and the universal relationship with other churches around the world and the Pentecostal churches often claim to be more revived form of Christianity and particularly trying to show as if they are the reformed version of the CSI or other established churches. Without attempting to bring in a physical union in the name of unity, is there any possible way of relating to each other and working together in the context of mission. It is also difficult to ask people to give up their superiority claims of the gospel version and tradition over other Christians. At times there are also exclusive claims of their traditional version of Christian faith.
It raises question about the concept of people of God or community of God as it is defined by the church. Today Christian communities have been internalised in India and thereby have become selfish and do not wish to provide service to wider communities in many cases. Even if they do through some projects they would prefer such services are provided with the support from abroad. Of course there are examples where Indigenous support is raised and development projects are run with local help only. They are only a few in numbers compared to other projects being supported by the outside agencies.
For this we may also have to find a way to enable Christians from different denominations to hold on to their traditions while exploring the possibility of working together in some common ways for the mission of God. This raises serious questions about the claims of ‘the Gospel truth’ that brings a confrontation between different denominations. While being committed to one’s own tradition, without being asked to merge or accept another tradition, can one work together with a person from another denomination and to see the common mission of the Gospel. In this sense the ‘Missio en Christo’ is a more appropriate term for our mission in God. Paul uses this phrase very often in his letters meaning being in Christ means we are different in our approach to Christ and thus need to maintain the difference but are united in a way to share those common tasks of mission together rather than sorting out our differences in tradition and faiths. We are radically different from each other because of our doctrines, traditions and understandings. There can no more be one single Christianity but Christianities but in Christ we are united together as the Body of Christ in which there are different parts and different roles played but are united in the sense there is something common that connects us. These common factors can be our investment for cultural ecumenism rather than looking for a merely physical unity or a wider union.
I am trying to find the union ‘in Christ’ as a more radical metaphor in which ‘the truth’ of each tradition can be accommodated and can also co-exist and possibly nourish and may be allowed to wrestle with each other at times as well. We have lived through a particular tradition which we believe in be the truth of the gospel, then we are called to proclaim this gospel while we are also called to correct and edify our mistakes. In this sense we are called to go back to our own tradition and learn from and through it our faith, then see the common elements with other traditions of Christian faith. We cannot make any judgement on other traditions as we have not lived in their traditions but at the same time when the relationship is stronger we can share some concerns about each other’s traditions in order to learn, correct and nourish each other. In this sense there is a uniqueness in each tradition and even universal relevance of each competing traditions has to be accepted but without judging other traditions as inferior or evil ones to their own. Learning of one’s own tradition should lead to this position by accepting the mystery of God beyond our comprehension and our limitation in understanding and explaining God experience through human language and narratives. While affirming the authentic Christian experiences we are called to find common denominators with other Christian traditions without compromising our own at times. Such a kind of understanding might enable the grassroots Lutherans to work closely with CSI members in creating a common space. It means we are not solving our differences but we are finding our common grounds to work together.
Multi-faith Community space
The church is the community of people whose lives are transformed by Jesus Christ, and who being rooted in him and empowered by him are committed to move people in the direction of the Kingdom. M M Thomas
Calling for the Church to be the Church is not a formula for a withdrawal ethic, not is it a self-righteous attempt to flee from the world’s problems; rather it is a call for church to be a community which tries to develop the resources to stand within the world witnessing to the peaceable kingdom and this rightly understanding the world… M M Thomas .
Creating such a community throws challenges to mission in India today. This provides a challenge for the churches because it shows that the churches are sincerely concerned about the poor in India and they wish to do something for the poor in India. Though we start with Christian community in terms of creating this space, without the involvement and activism of other religious communities such space may not be realistic in many places and can create misunderstanding for others. When we talk about creating community through churches, it raises many questions. The second issue that arises from the creation of such communities is to relate ourselves with people of other faiths in new ways. There are already three generally known ways of relating with people of other faiths – Pluralistic, Inclusive and Exclusive approaches . I would like to bring out a fourth approach, where Christians can maintain their own Christian faith while relating to people of other faiths in a new ways. Many Christians find it difficult to relate to their neighbours because they hold a kind of exclusive views about other faiths on the one hand and think that the only way to relate to other people is to invite them to Christianity. Many of them support missionaries and become themselves mission minded inviting people to Christian fellowship. Very often it leads to an offence or to an argument that leads friends of other faith to develop an anti-Christian attitude. On the one hand there are political self-interested groups such as BJP and other Hindutva groups create artificial fear among Hindus about Christians and also about Muslims and on the other there is a strong Charismatic and over enthusiastic Christian missionary groups tend to make claims of superiority over other religions and also condemn people of other faiths in strong manners.
I have talked about the ignorance created and sustained by the media and by a few Hindutva political and national parties in India in my previous articles . Such ignorance is spread through the mediated myths of communal hatredness and suspicions. I have also used the critique of Edward Said to question such ignorance which leads to generalisations and creates mass-phobia in the minds of the people at large in India . It is through such grassroots communities and their interactions such ignorance can be reduced and friendship can be established between various religions. An alternative community can bring people closer to each other directly where each one would try to establish a friendship through certainly myths may be clarified and thus ignorance is removed. The dialogue at different levels may have to aim at bringing people at grassroots closer together.
I do appreciate the dialogue initiatives carried at various levels in India particularly by Christian leaders, theologians and other organisations. They have created a better understanding among leaders and educated people. This has not penetrated the Christians at grassroots who tend to neglect anyone who supports a compromising attitude towards uniqueness and universal relevance of the Gospel. I would like to take this seriously that means for the sake of establishing an alternative community to transform the poverty, it has to work with the grassroots Christians in a large scale. In order to create communities at grassroots, there is a need for developing better relationship between people of different faiths. Such a relationship is not possible if we are asking Christians to compromise with their faith in the gospel.
The fourth approach to other religions is to allow Christians to hold the faith in the uniqueness and universal relevance of the Gospel and thus believe in their statement of faith that Jesus is the truth. This allows them to share their gospel being unique and relevant to their lives and also to others. But at the same time they do not need to offend other people’s faith and claim superiority over other faiths as the Christians do not have any experience of other people’s faith and their lives within their narratives. At the same time if Christians would like to share their gospel or faith to others, they must also allow others to share their faith to them. It means to listen to them, if possible first and then share with others Christian faith.
When we create community our prime purpose is to eliminate poverty and so that space, having been created by the Christians or church indirectly, it should not be a place for promoting Christianity though after establishing a good relationship through listening, there is a possibility. In short eliminating poverty should not be the means to persuade non-Christians to become Christians. But at the same time if people would like to know more about Christianity there should not be any hindrance or any prohibition on this. If enthusiastic Christians wish to use this space then they need to told to visit their houses or other places to communicate their faith rather than in this community space. If someone likes to join the Christian community as a member through conversion, careful consideration and time period should be given. Conversion is a decision taken by individuals who should not be on the basis of allurement, threat or fear or force. Even this community space should not be used for any attempts of conversion. The Christian community have to come openly and voluntarily against proselytisation using force, allurement or threat or any other wrong methods except through preaching and witnessing .
I would agree with the wider understanding of conversion as liberation from all that enslave us and prevent us being what God created us to be [Wingate 279]. For Wingate liberation should be the key to conversion which should to full freedom in every aspect of life, which includes social, economic and political, personal and religious fields. Basically the alternative community space aims at creating such a freedom among people from different background and thus brings them into the reign of God [Wingate 8]. While accepting the fact that Christians do invite people of other faiths through their lives, action and words to follow Christ but wrong methods and means should be avoided and eliminated altogether from the practices of evangelisation. As Christians we need to believe that it is the Holy Spirit that brings people to accept Christian gospel rather than human effort to bring them. Any human effort to persuade other people to Christian faith is against the gospel values and practices. It is an attempt to proselytise others which is challenged by Jesus himself. It is interesting to note that recently even the evangelical alliance have endorsed the code of conduct for conversion of people of other faiths into Christianity . But Christians can certainly say that they are involved in eliminating poverty because they try to follow Christ. It is because of Christ’s teaching and of witnessing Jesus’ life that they are involved.
If a Hindu or Muslim says similar statements Christians need not confront or offend rather in a good relationship and friendship such competition can be allowed and grow in a mature manner to give a space for them. We proclaim the gospel elsewhere and invite people to accept Christian faith on the one hand and on the other we do not wish to use this community space for such purposes unless asked for by the other members. This is a contradictory position but can be held together by Christians and thus engage in eliminating the poverty in India and thus witness the Gospel in this way. Christians are encouraged to hold onto their faith which claims to be the truth. It is their right to hold on to such faith and proclaim it in that way without any offence or superior claims over others. Christians cannot make any judgement on other people’s faiths as they have not experienced other’s faiths and also should not display the converts to claim that they moved from evil religion to the best religion.
Christians should also recognise the fact that the churches or Christian fellowships do not practice the Gospel in an ideal way rather they are as corrupt as others, as exploitative as any other organisations in the world. In spite of these limitations people are still trying to witness to the gospel and share the stories of Christ through their own life stories. It is essential for Christians to recognise these limitations of their claims and thus find a humble way to share their gospel to the people of other faiths. This is what I call as “Fourth way approach to people of other faiths” which leads the Christian community to be a sign of contradiction.. It means to say that we are not ashamed of proclaiming and witnessing the Gospel on the one hand and on the other we are serious and sincere about our relationship with people of other faiths. Christians do not have any secret agenda but have an agenda to witness the gospel through their action. Christians are ready to listen and accept people as they are without any change in their faiths. This can also be called a “fourth approach” where Christians are called to be honest with their friends about their faith in Christ while trying to recognise the image of God in all by not making judgement on their faith, their culture, their experiences and their religious narratives.
Bishop Newbigin has highlighted similar positions in his book Gospel in a Pluralist Society. On the one hand he wrote, “We must affirm the gospel as truth, universal truth, truth for all peoples and for all times which creates the possibility of freedom; but we negate the gospel if we deny the freedom in which along it can be truly believed.” (p.10) He wrote again, “To be its (gospel) witnesses does not mean to be the possessors of all truth. It means to be placed on the path by following which we are led toward the truth....when Christians affirm, as they do, that Jesus is the way, the true and living way by whom we come to the father (John 16:4), they are not claiming to know everything. They are claiming to be on the way, and inviting others to join them as they press forward toward the fullness of the truth, toward the day when we shall know as we have been known”. (page 11). This image of being in the journey clearly points out the fact that though we believe in the fullness and mystery of the truth which is yet be comprehended fully even by Christians. It means we affirm the faith in the gospel as the truth, proclaim in that way and invite others to join in our journey, but at the same time because we ourselves are not possessing the complete truth as we journey towards it, we cannot make any judgement on others or say we are superior to others though we claim the uniqueness and universal relevance of the gospel to all.
Newbigin stated his position as exclusivist because it affirmsed the unique truth of the revelation in Jesus Christ and as not exclusivist because he did not wish to deny the possibility of the salvation of the non-Christians (p182). In a sense he did not wish to make a judgement on the salvation of the non-Christians and leaves it as a possibility. His position is a pluralist position because it acknowledges the gracious work of God in the lives of all human beings and is not a pluralist because he does not wish to deny the uniqueness and decisiveness of what God has done in Jesus Christ p.183).In his book A Word in Season: Perspectives on Christian World Missions, Newbigin argued, the gospel can only be communicated to our plurarist society by communities that take the Bible as the fundamental framework of their thinking, as the way they understand the world and the human story. To live in this is not to pretend to know the whole truth or to be possessed of indubitable knowledge (p.165). Bishop Newbigin is not alone in struggling between two corresponding but paradoxical views which are: 1. Universal relevance and uniqueness of the Gospel which also highlights Jesus as the truth and 2. Universal activities and mystery of God which highlight God’s love for all beings and inability of human beings to comprehend or know God completely and also the necessity of recognising and loving other human beings in line with God’s love. These two are not necessarily contradictory within the faith in Christ and so can be held together by simple grassroots Christians.
In one of the HMI lectures Newbigin said, “There is an admirable humility about the statement that the truth is much greater than anyone can grasp, but it can be very deceptive when it is used to neutralise any confident affirmation of the truth. The story of five blind men describing an elephant is told in order to suggest that a proper humility will refrain from confident affirming “this is the truth” [Sings amid the Rubble: The purposes of God in Human history, edited by Geoffrey Wainwright, W B Eerdmann: 2003,p.65]. Again the inability of human beings to describe God and so our description of God should be done in humility even by refraining from confident affirmation of the claims of truth. For me I would argue that we should claim that Jesus is the Christ and the truth within our Christian faith which does not mean that there is no other ‘The Truth’ possible. We accept the fact that we do not know about other ‘The Truth’s and did not have any other experiences who claim to hold ‘The Truth besides our own Christian experience. If this is the case we cannot make any judgement on other claims nor claim ours as superior to theirs. Because of God’s mysteries and our limitations to fully comprehend God we cannot make claims of either exclusive or pluralistic or inclusive claims about the gospel, rather we accept that our gospel has to be lived, preached and practiced and also our gospel has universal significance and is unique. Thus Christians have something special to contribute to this world by inviting all people to follow Christ.
The basic purpose of this approach is to encourage Christians to engage honestly with people of other faiths at grassroots. In simple terms Christians would accept people of other faiths as they are while inviting others to accept Christians as they are. Nevertheless the task of the Christians is to establish relationship with people of other faiths at grassroots in order to create a community or a common space where there will be freedom for all to earn their livelihood. To enable Christians to engage in such opportunities this fourth way approach to people of other faiths would certainly be very helpful. On the one hand this will also become an inevitable mission act of God and thus demands every Christians to get involved in such activities and witness for Christ among others.
Inter-caste Community space
We began this wedding supper with singing, and concluded with prayer; between ten and eleven we returned home with joy. This was a glorious triumph over caste! A Brahman married to a Soodra, in the Christian way: Englishmen eating with the married couple and their friends, at the same table, and at the native house From William Carey’s diary .
The third issue is to face the crisis in identity by the churches and also by the community space that they create. Within and outside the churches the caste, regional, Tribal and linguistic identities make people to differentiate themselves. This becomes criteria for any group formations. Though many Christians come from Dalit, Tribal and Backward castes each group tends to distinguish each other within the churches. Thus divisions within and outside the church are well developed and are based on these identities. Even in Nagaland where many are Baptists the Tribal segregation does not allow at times the communities across different tribal people to come together.
CMS missionaries in Travancore in 1816 recognised the conditions of Pulayas – Dalits and campaigned against the system in 1850s by creating alternative Christian communities. This let to the confrontation and conflict with landlords and resulted in the Travancore Government’s bill declaring owning slaves as illegal [George Oommen, Dalit Conversion adn Social Protest in Travancore, 1854-1890, Bangalore Theological Forum 3 &4, Sept-Dec 1996, pp.69-84]. It was the church schools (1840-1890s) that provided a space for different caste pupils to sit together [Clarke 2003,Conversion to Christianity in Tamil Nadu: in Religious Conversion in India edited by R Robinson and S Clarke (eds) New Delhi: OUP, p.343 and Ghose, S 2003, The Dalit in India, Social Research, 70(1), 83-109.]. The churches in India particularly in the South India are struggling with the caste differences and discrimination. Particularly Dalit and Tribal communities are struggling to break these caste barriers even after becoming Christians. They are discriminated even by the fellow Christians from other communities. I should also recognise the fact that there were movements led by Ambedkar and E V Ramasamy Periyar in India. They tried to eliminate the caste structures and developed counter ideologies against caste ideologies (Varna Dharma). In spite of their movements, the caste discrimination among Indian communities is increasing in new ways particularly among non-Christian backgrounds. Among Christians there are more implicit ways of discrimination such as resistance for inter-caste marriages and getting positions within the churches and so on. In the article ‘The Emerging Dalit Theology: A Historical Appraisal, George Oommen has clearly pointed out there are theologians such as A P Nirmal, James Massey, M E Prabhkara, M Azariah, K Wilson, V.Devasahayam and F J Balasundaram who have written extensively about Dalit issues and counter theologies [The Emerging Dalit Theology: A Historical Approach, Indian Church History Review, Vol XXXIV, number 1, June 2000, pp.19-37]. Some of the theologies emerged as exclusive of previous Indian Christian Theologies as they were mainly influenced by Brahminical philosophies. Balasundaram makes the point, Dalit theology is not and can’t be exclusive. A theology that is exclusive can’t be Christian. Dalit Theology is pursued for others’ liberation also [F J Balasundaram, Dalit Struggle, Unpublished Manuscripts, pp2f – quoted by George Oommen in the Emerging Theology and also in Dalits and Christian Mission in the Tamil Country, Bangalore: ATC, 1997]. K Wilson affirms this by going further, “Christian Dalit theology does not forbid Christian Dalits from working with non-Dalit authentic Christians, the renascent Hindus, the reformed Muslims and humanistic forces from various other faiths and ideologies, on a common human platform and thus hasten the process of establishing a human and humane culture which is why the Word Became flesh [K.Wilson, Twice Alienated: Culture of Dalit Christians, Hyderabad 1982]. There is a clear willingness even among Dalit theologians to find a common space between Dalits and other communities where one would recognise the other with human dignity and see in each other the image of God. The famous theologian Michael Amaladoss writes, the focus (of Dalit Theology/Indian Christian theology) is not merely on the oppression and God’s option for the oppressed, but on the new community of freedom and fellowship, love and justice, which is the new people of the reign of God to which God calls all people [Michael Amaladoss, Life in Freedom: Liberation Theologies from Asia. Marknoll: Orbis, 1997, p.31]. The Tribal theologies emphasised much of communitarian nature of Tribals in North East India particularly which invites people from other communities to join in their liberative processes. My interest here is to create a space among people from different castes, language groups, regions and tribes within a particular community in order to create a space for freedom and thus eliminate unfreedom. If the barriers evolve in terms of caste or tribe then Christians have to engage to create a space not merely to come together but to engage with each other.
One should also notice the fact that majority of the people who are below poverty lines are from Dalits, Tribal and Backward communities. Economically, socially and psychologically they are discriminated in various parts of India. The ‘unfreedom’ are constructed ideologically and psychologically. If Christians are sincere then they should not only look to work among the Christain Dalits or Christian Tribal or Christian Backward communities. They should establish a wider community not only liberating from their own boundaries or from their self captivity [James Massey Down Trodden, 1997, WCC] but also liberating non Christian Dalits, Tribes, backward castes and even linguistic minorities and leading them to a new community in Christ. When Christians creates a community space it is essential that each one not only develops a freedom to earn one’s own livelihood but also develops a freedom to express oneself and also a necessity to recognise and respect each other’s human dignity and lives at par with each other.
Forming this community means it challenges both churches and the society at large in India and elsewhere the practices of caste discrimination. Fairness and equal opportunities alone cannot help the churches to take side with those who are affected by the caste system in India. It is essential that the church needs to identify herself with the suffering people. Having come from a Tribal background which is both oppressed and used as a instrument to oppress other communities by the upper castes, there is a need for giving all an opportunity to come together within this community but at the same time the poor and the marginalised should be supported in order to enable them to assert their identities and their intelligence at par with others. So this community needs to allow sharing of people’s difficulties and sufferings so that others would not only sympathise but also become aware of others and their dignity and issues.
There should be a better relationship built in order to eliminate the poverty but also this relationship is not real unless everyone’s dignity is respected and recognised. So creation of such community should include all and should also try a learning and sharing process where ignorance about each other can be reduced and prophetically challenge and eliminate some of discrimination in the name of caste, regionalism, tribal identity, language within the wider society and even within the churches. If we use the concept of image of God in human beings it comes into confrontation with the other religious concepts such as the image of Brahman with diverse castes. As Christians we need affirm that being “in Christ ()” for Paul might have used the shortened version of fellowship with Christ and belonging to Christ (A Schweitzer, The mysticism of Apostle Paul, ET London 1953, p.16) . Dunn argues it refers to having a consciousness of Christ [Jesus and the Spirit, London, 1975, 324]. Though we cannot frame Paul’s use of ‘in Christ’ with one track of meaning, Paul’s use does not merely refer to an act of “mystical partaking in the spiritual being of Christ” (as Schweitzer would like us to think) rather he uses it to refer to the community in Christ . In Romans 12:5, it refers to the community in Christ, (so in Christ we who are many form one body, and each member belongs to all the others.). It is oneness of the community in Christ and among themselves being united. Paul uses the imagery of the body to describe the church and also the imagery of husband and wife relationship for the communion of the Christians with Christ. We do not become Christ nevertheless we are part of the body of Christ. There is a new creation which is not a mere individualistic rather communitarian. I would even strongly say that only community is identified as new creation. We affirm the fact that there is no male nor female no Jew no Gentile but then what about people of other faiths we cannot impose on them such concepts, though it is very relevant for Christians (Galatians 3:28). It does not mean the differences are eliminated, rather there is no discrimination based on differences.
When we become one in Christ the weak part of the body gets more attention, in the same way the weaker and vulnerable sections should be given priorities in our programmes. The husband and wife imagery provides a fascinating union but not necessarily into a homogenous body. All cannot become the same but in Christ nothing can be considered as superior or inferior. So for me being in Christ means there is no discrimination which is used as an equivalent of ‘Christians’. Paul clearly refers to a community space where believers is transformed and united with Christ and also with fellow believers in Christ. Before we move to develop the community space for freedoms, then we as Christians need to recognise the community space in Christ which is the Christian church or Christian community or fellowship. In this fellowship there is not only no discrimination and no exploitation but also there is caring service, welcoming community and sharing resources. This community invites all including people of other castes, of other tribes or of other religions to be part of this core community where such freedoms are exercised.
Being a transformative community in Christ (which means Christians being transformative), now the question is how to bring about transformation among other communities? Or how to create wider community where such freedoms can also be realised without converting everyone to Christ or including those who do not wish to follow Christ? Here we need to recognise the fact that there are others who work among the communities as catalysis of transformation. Ramakrishna mission and Self Employed Women Association (SEWA) are good examples of agencies of poverty alleviation. If it is God’s will that the poverty of the people should be alleviated then they fulfil God’s plan through their agencies though they are not Christians. There are agencies who work for promoting community development and for the respect of human dignity. They too realise that every human beings are created in the image of God and thus wish to recognise their dignity. This provides a challenge to transit from merely being in Christ (to being in God (
We not only participate in God’s mission but also we belong to God. If we are one with Christ we are also one with God. This will have wider implications for our working with these communities and transforming them. In monistic Hinduism there is a strong belief that everything comes and goes into the Ultimate Reality (Brahman). The relationship between God and Ultimate Reality and human beings are complex and mysterious one. But there is oneness with Ultimate Being is very much emphasised. Even though we cannot compare oneness in Christ and oneness with God as the same thing as oneness with the ultimate being which can be interpreted in a similar manner to encourage and identify the other people and their dignities regardless of caste practices. In a sense the oneness with God has to be interpreted for Christians and also with other people within their religious faiths in a way the human dignity is recognised and respected. This would certainly help to eliminate or reduce any discrimination and exploitation in Indian society.
Being one with God enables us to be part of Trinitarian mission. As Trinitarian community of God guides us to engage and encourage people see them as part of being one with God. It means in no way that we are equal with God. We cannot claim ourselves to be gods. Rather we can become one with God in a sense of we are working as co-workers with God while we also recognise the fact that God is already working outside Christianity too in terms of eradication of poverty. As we are one with God we are called to recognise such great work of others and possibly join with them in forming the community of freedom. If we are one with God having accepted Christ and being one in Christ as new creation, then we also have a share in God’s work and mission. As we recognise in each other the image of God we recognise in each other God. In our action God’s action can be revealed. In our lives God’s plans and mind are revealed. Our mind, action, life and everything reveal God. When we move into this communitarian action God moves. Though we have limited understanding of God and cannot contain God in our lives alone, still we can become one with God in every sense. In the same way we invite other friends to become one with their God and thus reveal God’s action and mind in their actions. Many other friends and organisations work with the same mind and with same interests in eliminating poverty, caste discrimination and bringing harmony between different religious communities, then they do reveal God’s mind and action in their activities.
We all work as a widened community of God in which God is also not only present but partake. When we turn a exploiter into one who upholds Dalits, when we convert a rich to share and enable the poor and to eliminate poverty, when we enable communities not to kill each other in the name of religion and in the name of their differences, then we make the community of God to have joy among themselves. When God want to do these, we are there to do on God’s behalf. We play the role of God in many places. Though we are not gods but we bring joy and happiness within Godhood by carrying out God’s intentions and actions in this world (Luke 15). We are able to understand the dialogue within Trinitarian God and being changes within Godhood through our mission. By recognising and participating along with others beyond religious boundaries we are able to see God’s plan outside our communities and recognise in each other God’s mind, plans and actions for this world. This is why I call this as mission within God’s community. What God wants within God’s Trinitarian community we are fulfilling and thus carrying out God’s mission. Thus we engage within God’s community and partake in God in doing mission. This means we do mission in God or we become one with God through Christ in doing Mission. This takes us beyond mission eccelesia , missio dei and mission humanitatis (Thomas Thangaraj). This is why I call this as mission in God where we recognise God’s involvement outside the church and also outside the Christianity too. Where we cannot do it alone we have to join with other or work with others or participate in others’ programme or even appreciate others’ work by recognising it as part of the mission of God. Mission in God is different from others because it is not certainly church centred rather Christ centred (possibly God centred); it is also not merely showing solidarity with the poor or downtrodden rather faith and life centred with a belief in God’s transformative power and in the abiding power of God in and through the transforming community which brings joy within Godhood; it is not merely the mission of God as it brings the involvement and participation of human beings within Godhood as Jesus’ humanity was accepted into Godhood to continue his mission in God. Mission is a joint collaboration of God and human beings. What is thought to be an initiative in the mind of a human being to bring about transformation among the community may be accepted by God as God’s own initiative for such transformation. In this sense what arises in the mind of a human person brings about happiness and joy in the Trinitarian God. Thus human beings too are involved in this special mission of brining happiness and joy within Godhood by bringing about this transformation among human beings (Luke 15) for which they are also invited. This supports God’s participation in our mission and our participation in God’s mission.
My fourth way missiology will emphasise on this mission en Christo along with missio en theo in order to work with the friends and cooperating agencies who work closely with us seeing in them God’s mind and action. Unless we see other activities as part of God’s work and thus being part of God it is difficult to recognise in each other the image of God or Godhood and thus recognise in each other their dignity and their identity. This works well with the Fourth Way Missiology because we hold the truth in Christ and its universal and uniqueness but at the same time we cannot contain God in any form even within any one religion as God is beyond our ability to know and comprehend fully. We are convinced of the need for sharing the Gospel to all, we Christians need to recognise the fact that the power, money and other evil structures and cultural narratives have distorted the Gospel and its narratives. So within our limitations we do not wish to compromise in any way proclaiming and sharing our faith in Jesus as the truth for all but at the same time we have also failed to reveal him completely in our lives and actions. Fourth Way Missiology provides a new platform for us to be what we are but at the same time establish a good relationship with people of other faiths, engage with them in recognising God in each other and their dignity and work together to create a community space where poverty can be eliminated by sharing or participating. We are open for Christian conversion but strongly against any proselytising attempts of other religious friends and thus block our own mission in eliminating poverty. When we wish to share we should be ready to listen, listen to their faith stories, listen to their criticism about our faith and also listen to their life stories. We have to convert ourselves first in the sense of accepting their human dignity as they are, then only they will also accept us as we are.
Ending with the Theology of Lotus
I wish to end my paper by looking at the logos of a few churches in India. You may look at them carefully and please identify a few common pictures in them. I recognise two common features in the logos of the Church of South India (CSI), the Church of North India (CNI), the Marthoma Church, United Evangelical Lutheran Church in India (UELCI) and Malankara Churches in India. These two features are the cross and the Lotus. Both are rooted in clay or earth. The wood on the cross is hanging on the other wood with or without the support of a nail whereas the Lotus plant floats in the water. The Lotus flower leap outside the water as Jesus’ death on the cross is seen as leaving this world to the world beyond. I find three things in common between these two features – being rooted in the earth, floating in the air or water and leaping beyond which I would like to use as metaphors for my understanding of mission. One should keep in mind that there are different varieties of lotuses with different colours and different characteristics. Also there may be many lotus plants in one pond too.
These need to be kept in mind when we will discuss about the ecumenical mission within and outside the churches today. The CSI logo is explained in the following way,
The symbols, the lotus and the Christian cross, used in the logo of the church possess a rich cultural heritage in India which is used to symbolize the call and mission of the CSI. In Indian mythology, the lotus flower is the seat of the Creator. It is also known variably as those that are born in mud and the flower of the sun. These symbolisms are adopted to interpret the position of God, and the nature and role of the people in the CSI .
This explains why they had chosen to embed cross on lotus in the logo of CSI. But the lotus has other religious meanings in Hindu and Buddhist contexts. In Hinduism lotus flower often represents beauty and non-attachment .
For me lotus refers to being rooted in the earth which means being rooted in our identities –religious, cultural, social, linguistic and national identities. We need to be rooted in our Christian faith and tradition whatever we have inherited. Our Christian mission becomes meaningless unless we are rooted in Christ. Our faith is in Christ and we are witnesses for Christ. Lotus also refers to floating according to the current and level of the water which means to react to the issues and crises of the contexts around us with an approach of holiness. It means while we engage with the issues in our contexts we are non-attached from them in a way that they would not corrupt our lives. When the context changes and struggles with poverty and disasters we are called to engage in such crises with the mind of Christ as Lotus grows or shortens its stem according to height of the plant and moves according to the currents but still being rooted in the mud. Third point is to recognise the lotus leaping out of the water to show its beauty. It means God’s beauty is not revealed unless we leap beyond our boundaries and engage with the other in a positive and creative way. We can witness only when we leap out of our Christian identity and Christian community to serve wider community. This means not only leaping out of the water but also showing the flower to those above water. The beauty of the Christian gospel can be revealed in and through our lives only when we relate with other people, recognise their dignity, engage in creating with them a community of freedom. These are three important mission signposts that I will be coming back to. If we are deeply rooted in Christ, we will be able to create a community of God – an alternative community where God will be present, Christ will be active and the spirit will inspire toward freedom of all which will lead to alleviation of poverty and also dawning of the reign of God on earth. For Christians this is one of the best ways of doing mission in India.
Relating to British Context:
We need to be rooted in Christ which means to be one in Christ and share Christ with others. While we share Christ with others we are also called to relate to all who are different from us in culture, race and language. To relate we have to transcend (leap out) the Christian community and reach out to others outside. While we transcend the Christian community to build a wider community we are called to bear witness to Christ by addressing and by participating in the crises of the people around us. This means to address to provide support for the people who are part of such community. Developing such alternative community space may enable Christians to witness Christ, to alleviate poverty and relate themselves with others who share the image of God. It means that Christians are called to reach out to those outside the church and engage with them in doing God’s mission outside the church. Building relationship, recognising each other dignity and creating a space for freedom are part and parcel of Christian mission. If this can happen in the culture outside the church among the youth, among the poor here and among the marginalised, let us begin or do God’s mission there. In British context, the best way of doing mission are: to recognise the presence of others around us, to establish friendship and good relationship with them, to listen their stories and engage with them in their crises, to share our life stories of the gospel, to create together with them a community of freedom and service through which we may eliminate poverty and to invite them to follow Christ. By doing this humbly with the power of the Holy Spirit, we will bring the reign of God in and through the alternative community space and bring about transformation among the people and thus to bear witness to Christ in every possible ways.
Saturday, August 27, 2011
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)